Dr. Swaiman Singh, a prominent figure during the 2020-21 Indian farmers’ protest, faced an unexpected confrontation from pro-Khalistan individuals during a public appearance at a New York gurdwara on Sunday. The incident unfolded at the New York Sikh Cultural Society in Richmond Hill, where Dr. Singh had been invited to speak alongside former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo.
The tension reportedly stemmed from Dr. Singh’s public display of the Indian national flag during the farmers’ movement—an act that angered a section of the Sikh diaspora who view the Indian state through the lens of the traumatic events of 1984. The protest against his presence came just days ahead of the anniversary of Operation Bluestar, the Indian Army’s controversial military action at the Golden Temple on June 6, 1984.
Despite the disruption, Dr. Singh remained composed and delivered his scheduled address. Speaking candidly, he acknowledged the anguish that continues to simmer within the global Sikh community over the 1984 attack and the lack of justice for the victims. “I understand the pain, and I too feel it. But as an Indian, I will always hold my country’s flag with pride,” he said.
Dr. Singh emphasized a critical distinction between the actions of a particular political regime and the identity of the nation itself. “What happened in 1984 was the doing of a specific government, not the soul of India. We can and should hold governments accountable without denouncing our nation.”
He also addressed the broader issue of identity politics within the diaspora, revealing that he himself had previously been labeled a “Khalistani”—a tag he rejects. “Labeling voices that seek unity as extremist is not the way forward. The country needs to listen to Sikh grievances and act on them, but internal divisions will not help our cause,” he asserted.
The gurdwara, known as a vibrant hub for Sikh culture and intergenerational dialogue, became a rare scene of confrontation on Sunday. However, Dr. Singh used the moment to call for greater understanding and communication within the community. “This incident highlights the importance of creating space for respectful debate, rather than deepening divides,” he said.
Originally from Punjab’s Tarn Taran district, Dr. Singh has built a reputation not just as a vocal advocate for farmers’ rights, but also as a humanitarian. His organization, the 5 Rivers Heart Association, provided crucial medical services during the farmers’ protest at the Delhi borders, setting up camps and treating thousands.
While the confrontation in New York revealed the complex dynamics within the global Sikh community, Dr. Singh’s message of unity and justice resonated with many. His stance underscores an urgent need for nuanced conversations—where patriotism, pain, and progress can coexist without vilification.
