The relationship between two great democracies, Canada and India, is on thin ice, especially after the recent unfounded accusations from Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. The abrupt declaration that India could have had a hand in the assassination of a Canadian Sikh leader, Hardeep Singh Nijjar, is not only bewildering but might also signify a new low in the bilateral relations of these countries.
At its core, this accusation seems to be rooted more in prejudice and less in fact. India’s outrage is hardly surprising for a nation that has always championed the fight against terrorism on a global stage. For Canada, however, such a hasty judgment might prove costly. Instead of basing relationships on mutual respect and understanding, Canada’s unwarranted support for extremist groups, notably the Khalistan movement, poses a real threat to international collaboration.
To draw an analogy, Canada’s stance feels eerily similar to Pakistan’s known interference in India’s domestic matters. The consistent efforts to undermine and misrepresent India’s intentions have been a characteristic feature of Pakistan’s approach. By making these baseless allegations, Canada seems to be mirroring that kind of behavior. Labeling Canada as another Pakistan to India might seem strong, but if Canada continues on this trajectory, it risks being seen in the same light.
India-Canada ties are delicate and have faced tensions in recent years. While nations will undoubtedly have differences in perspectives and policies, making public accusations without substantive proof only serves to exacerbate an already fragile relationship. Such unfounded claims do not only strain political and diplomatic ties but also create unwarranted fear and anxiety among the Indian-Canadian community. It’s distressing to see such divisions being fueled further by unsubstantiated statements from the top echelons of the Canadian government.
Trudeau’s allegations indeed raise concerns, but not about India’s role in Nijjar’s assassination. Instead, it raises questions about Canada’s intentions and the direction of its foreign policy. It is imperative to ask why Canada is inclined to support extremist narratives without concrete evidence.
Canada’s image as a neutral, fair, and principled nation on the international stage is at stake. Isolating India based on shaky ground might lead Canada down a perilous path where it stands alone, having traded a trusted democratic partner for extremist ideologies.
It’s crucial for Canada to reassess its stance and base its actions and statements on clear evidence, rather than unfounded allegations. Solidarity, mutual respect, and evidence-based decision-making should be the pillars of Canada-India ties. Only by embracing these principles can both nations move towards a better future together.
The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author. They do not purport to reflect the opinions or views of Khalsa Vox or its members.